{"handle":"business-frameworks/ethics/feasible@1.6.1","path":"ethics/feasible","version":"1.6.1","title":"Feasible first: strike, draw the line, seek the middle way, then rank","layer":2,"free":true,"tokens":985,"tokens_terse":188,"budget":985,"price_usd":0,"children":["business-frameworks/ethics/feasible/pricing-law-reference@1.6.1"],"related":["business-frameworks/ethics@1.6.1","business-frameworks/ethics/risk@1.6.1","business-frameworks/decision@1.6.1","business-frameworks/decision/effort@1.6.1","business-frameworks/decision/extension@1.6.1","business-frameworks/ethics/decide/safety-concern@1.6.1","business-frameworks/ethics/decide/disclose@1.6.1"],"cites":["Harris, C. E., Pritchard, M. S. and Rabins, M. J., Engineering Ethics: Concepts and Cases, 4th ed., Wadsworth/Cengage Learning, 2009","National Society of Professional Engineers, Code of Ethics for Engineers (as cited in Harris, Pritchard and Rabins 2009)"],"shape":null,"text":"Before ranking options, make three passes. Strike the clear cases: an act local law forbids (the caller states the law), serious harm to people who did not accept it and cannot be made whole, deception about a material fact, a broken signed obligation, a price raised beyond the seller's own rise in cost on a buyer who needs the product for life or health and has no other source or time to find one. A known defect stays a defect until a test shows it is safe. Place each gray case between a clearly wrong and a clearly acceptable example, weighing the features that matter most. Where two legitimate duties collide, look for an option that honors both before choosing. Rank only what survives. Any decision about a person — hiring, pay, promotion, discipline, dismissal, refusing credit or service — keeps a person in the loop who holds the final call: qualified to judge it, authorized to decide it, accountable for it.\n\nRefusal lines. Safety: exposure above the applicable standard, or risk knowingly placed on people who were not free to refuse, were not told, or could not judge it, is struck unless it can be fully made good, which is never true of death or lasting injury. Ordinary risk within the standard is priced. Harm that falls on a few while many gain is compensated and priced unless it also fails that test. A case that passes only by claiming a benefit nobody else can supply returns not assessed: that weighing belongs to the public and its regulators. Honesty: a number met by hiding what it measures is struck, and so is holding back a fact the other side would reasonably expect to hear. In a bargain the settled ends are keeping one's own limit and alternatives private, which is acceptable, and a false statement of fact or of one's authority to agree, which is struck. In a price the settled ends are charging what the product is worth to a buyer who can wait or go elsewhere, which is acceptable, and raising the price of something needed for life or health, on a buyer with no other source and no time to find one, by more than the seller's own cost has risen, which is struck. A false figure given to a government is struck as deception, like any other; what must be reported, and in what form, follows the law test and returns not assessed until the caller states the local law. Law: the caller supplies the legal facts after counsel; the node applies the rule, never a statute, and no country is the default. Conduct toward rivals, resellers and buyers returns not assessed until counsel has ruled: any understanding with a rival on prices, territories or customers, or one arranged among one's own suppliers or resellers; current cost or price data exchanged with a rival; making one product a condition of buying another, or an exclusive deal covering most buyers; terms on what resellers may charge, or different prices to resellers who compete; a price cut that pays only once a rival has gone, where a cut that pays on its own is competition. For all but an understanding among rivals, the first question for counsel is whether buyers could go elsewhere. Signed obligations, training contracts included, are honored to term. Records that bear on a dispute the firm can foresee are kept, and nobody is asked to discard them. Competence: a judgment given outside the giver's field is not assessed until a competent reviewer is named. Burden of proof: a known defect stays a defect until a test shows it is safe; past launches without failure prove nothing. Unknowns: a missing fact that would change the answer returns not assessed, with the question that settles it. Any decision about a person — hiring, pay, promotion, discipline, dismissal, or refusing someone credit or service — has a person in the loop who holds the final call, whatever a system recommends: someone qualified to judge it, with the delegated authority to decide it, and accountable for it. The system aids a process that should be objective and based on merit. Decide a policy that leaves some better off and others worse as if you did not yet know which group you would be in. A bias nobody intends does not show in intentions, so look at results: once a year, set who was hired, paid more and promoted beside who was eligible. In a small firm that is a one-page tally, and a gap in it is a question to ask, since a few cases prove nothing. Not struck on consequence alone: a lawful, fairly run price change, separation or closure is ranked against its alternatives.\n\nBorderline cases are real, but so is the difference between their ends; comparing against settled examples, and deciding like cases alike, keeps the line consistent. When a cost-benefit test and a consent test agree, proceed with confidence; when they split, a redesigned option — consent sought, harm compensated, exposure removed — often reunites them.","variants":{"terse":"the lede alone","full":"lede, conditions and reasoning","agent":"the same accepted text as fields (served with ?variant=agent): scope, inputs, rule, action, check, reasoning, units, example, apply, recheck, recheck_note, closing_citation; the same price"},"versions":["1.6.1","1.6","1.5","1.4"],"variant":"full","levels":{"lede":"Before ranking options, make three passes. Strike the clear cases: an act local law forbids (the caller states the law), serious harm to people who did not accept it and cannot be made whole, deception about a material fact, a broken signed obligation, a price raised beyond the seller's own rise in cost on a buyer who needs the product for life or health and has no other source or time to find one. A known defect stays a defect until a test shows it is safe. Place each gray case between a clearly wrong and a clearly acceptable example, weighing the features that matter most. Where two legitimate duties collide, look for an option that honors both before choosing. Rank only what survives. Any decision about a person — hiring, pay, promotion, discipline, dismissal, refusing credit or service — keeps a person in the loop who holds the final call: qualified to judge it, authorized to decide it, accountable for it.","conditions":"Refusal lines. Safety: exposure above the applicable standard, or risk knowingly placed on people who were not free to refuse, were not told, or could not judge it, is struck unless it can be fully made good, which is never true of death or lasting injury. Ordinary risk within the standard is priced. Harm that falls on a few while many gain is compensated and priced unless it also fails that test. A case that passes only by claiming a benefit nobody else can supply returns not assessed: that weighing belongs to the public and its regulators. Honesty: a number met by hiding what it measures is struck, and so is holding back a fact the other side would reasonably expect to hear. In a bargain the settled ends are keeping one's own limit and alternatives private, which is acceptable, and a false statement of fact or of one's authority to agree, which is struck. In a price the settled ends are charging what the product is worth to a buyer who can wait or go elsewhere, which is acceptable, and raising the price of something needed for life or health, on a buyer with no other source and no time to find one, by more than the seller's own cost has risen, which is struck. A false figure given to a government is struck as deception, like any other; what must be reported, and in what form, follows the law test and returns not assessed until the caller states the local law. Law: the caller supplies the legal facts after counsel; the node applies the rule, never a statute, and no country is the default. Conduct toward rivals, resellers and buyers returns not assessed until counsel has ruled: any understanding with a rival on prices, territories or customers, or one arranged among one's own suppliers or resellers; current cost or price data exchanged with a rival; making one product a condition of buying another, or an exclusive deal covering most buyers; terms on what resellers may charge, or different prices to resellers who compete; a price cut that pays only once a rival has gone, where a cut that pays on its own is competition. For all but an understanding among rivals, the first question for counsel is whether buyers could go elsewhere. Signed obligations, training contracts included, are honored to term. Records that bear on a dispute the firm can foresee are kept, and nobody is asked to discard them. Competence: a judgment given outside the giver's field is not assessed until a competent reviewer is named. Burden of proof: a known defect stays a defect until a test shows it is safe; past launches without failure prove nothing. Unknowns: a missing fact that would change the answer returns not assessed, with the question that settles it. Any decision about a person — hiring, pay, promotion, discipline, dismissal, or refusing someone credit or service — has a person in the loop who holds the final call, whatever a system recommends: someone qualified to judge it, with the delegated authority to decide it, and accountable for it. The system aids a process that should be objective and based on merit. Decide a policy that leaves some better off and others worse as if you did not yet know which group you would be in. A bias nobody intends does not show in intentions, so look at results: once a year, set who was hired, paid more and promoted beside who was eligible. In a small firm that is a one-page tally, and a gap in it is a question to ask, since a few cases prove nothing. Not struck on consequence alone: a lawful, fairly run price change, separation or closure is ranked against its alternatives.","reasoning":"Borderline cases are real, but so is the difference between their ends; comparing against settled examples, and deciding like cases alike, keeps the line consistent. When a cost-benefit test and a consent test agree, proceed with confidence; when they split, a redesigned option — consent sought, harm compensated, exposure removed — often reunites them."},"url":"https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/ethics/feasible","children_urls":["https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/ethics/feasible/pricing-law-reference"],"related_urls":["https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/ethics","https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/ethics/risk","https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/decision","https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/decision/effort","https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/decision/extension","https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/ethics/decide/safety-concern","https://business-frameworks.matryoshka-paradigms.workers.dev/node/ethics/decide/disclose"],"cite_as":"McHenry, J. (2026). Business Frameworks, version 1.6.1, business-frameworks/ethics/feasible@1.6.1."}